Clean and Grungy {one} - input please :)

[joyfulheartdesigns]

Howdy, chickadees! :yo: I am trying something new here...and half of it is quite difficult for me...being clean is tough to do!!! :decision:

I have decided to offer both the clean, no texture at all, version of some of my paper packs, and then the grungy version, which I prefer...what do you guys think?
Is this an option that you think is valuable? It was so hard to hit save and move on with the clean papers!! :drama: LOL
I know some people prefer no texture at all, though. Any feedback is uber welcome op2:

 

[taxed4ever]

Well I think its a great idea! Not everyone likes grunge, (I love it but others don't) So I can see this being a wise decision!

 

[CourtneyDesigns]

These are gorgeous!

 

[Madi]

I like the grungy look ,
and clean papers can still have texture?

 

[SharLamb]

I associate you with GRUNGY. You might get a new following with the clean. ??? Not much to lose by giving it a shot.

 

[bcgal00]

I love both so in my opinion it's a wonderful option to have both versions!

 

[bcgal00]

Also, many may like the clean version which they can distress themselves.

 

[ninigoesdigi]

I think it's a nice idea but I prefer my papers with texture, lighter than what you usually have but here with no texture at all it feels weird to me :giggle:
IMO, it's "paper" so even if it's not distressed and grunge like you have at the bottom, I feel that it still needs a light... subtle texture. Hope this helps.
Colors are yummy by the way!

 

[faerywings]

Great paper packs!!
Of course, I love grungy papers but ITA with the wise women who have posted before me- great idea to offer both to widen the customer base.

Have you made grunge overlays at all? It would be cool to offer them as a way that people can grunge/texturize your clean papers to the level they like.

 

[Danesa]

Even though I'm a grungy gal I love that you're offering both!

 

[joyfulheartdesigns]

Thanks so much for all of the feedback, guys!! The clean version could still have a light paper texture on it, but I have been seeing quite a bit of digital paper with no texture on it at all...I think the people who do a lot of printing might prefer that because you end up with the real paper texture on the piece of paper you just printed on. I could possibly do a third version with a real paper texture on it - a light one...that is a lot of versions though! lol Decisions, decisions...

Chris, yep, I could offer overlays for them to apply themselves...another good idea!

Thank you, ladies!!

 

[veer]

I love to scrap clean, but i prefer your the grunge papers !