It's a challenge, isn't it Heather? I feel the same way some times...love doing it, but hate leaving anything out, then how to deal with them all!
But I know you can do it!!
I am having this problem with the pics from my niece's trip in June...hundreds of photos, I love them all! They are intended for a book. I already have 34 pages, almost all multi-photo, and I am not near the end yet!
I have more photos from weeks 35 and 36, but I try to at least start with my POTD, then I can supplement with more pages.